Saturday, August 2, 2008

Whistle-Blower Suits Languish at Justice.....

I wonder why?
Hmmm..........Who do we know IN the WHITE HOUSE that would like to hide this? How much has been paid and to whom?
Instead, we can think about Paris and Brittany!
BOY, are we just a bunch of DUMB AMERICANS
DO not knwo what we have until we lose it and this BUSH has really progressed in that department now hasn't he?

July 3rd, 2008 5:18 pm
A Backlog Of Cases Alleging Fraud

Whistle-Blower Suits Languish at Justice

By Carrie Johnson / Washington Post

More than 900 cases alleging that government contractors and drugmakers have defrauded taxpayers out of billions of dollars are languishing in a backlog that has built up over the past decade because the Justice Department cannot keep pace with the surge in charges brought by whistle-blowers, according to lawyers involved in the disputes.

The issue is drawing renewed interest among lawmakers and nonprofit groups because many of the cases involve the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, rising health-care payouts, and privatization of government functions -- all of which offer rich new opportunities to swindle taxpayers.

Since 2001, 300 to 400 civil cases have been filed each year by employees charging that their companies defrauded the government. But under the cumbersome process that governs these cases, Justice Department lawyers must review them under seal, and whistle-blowers routinely wait 14 months or longer just to learn whether the department will get involved. The government rejects about three-quarters of the cases it receives, saying that the vast majority have little merit.

Disputes can stay buried for years more while the government investigates the allegations.

"Even if no new cases are filed, it might take 10 years for the Department of Justice to clear its desk. Cases in the backlog represent a lot of money being left on the table," said Patrick Burns, a spokesman for Taxpayers Against Fraud, which advocates for Justice to receive more funding to support cases by whistle-blowers and their attorneys.

Supporters of federal intervention in the cases say the dividends are substantial: In recent years, verdicts and settlements have returned nearly $13 billion to the U.S. government.

At issue in most of the cases is whether companies knowingly sold defective products or overcharged federal agencies for items sold at home or offered to U.S. troops overseas. Under the Civil War-era False Claims Act, workers who file lawsuits alleging such schemes cannot discuss them or even disclose their existence until Justice decides whether to step in.

By its own account, the 75-lawyer unit in Washington that reviews the sensitive lawsuits is overloaded and understaffed. Only about 100 cases a year are investigated by the team, which works out of the commercial litigation branch of Justice's civil division.

Critics argue that the delays are at least partly the result of foot-dragging by Justice and the federal agencies whose position it represents, especially in the touchy area of suppliers that may have overbilled the government for equipment, food and other items used by troops in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Justice lawyers have rejected about 19 cases involving contractor fraud in Iraq and Afghanistan, registering five settlements that resulted in $16 million, officials said. Government officials said this week that they are considering whether to dive into 32 more whistle-blower cases involving Iraq or the Middle East.

"It's just flatly absurd for us to be five years into this war" with so few public cases, said Alan Grayson, a whistle-blower lawyer in Florida who has criticized the Justice effort and who is running for Congress as a Democrat.

In a statement, Justice spokesman Charles Miller said that career lawyers and supervisors base their determinations on merit, not on political sensitivities. "Our decisions to intervene or decline in cases involving Iraq and the Middle East are entirely consistent with our record in [whistle-blower] cases generally," he said.

Help from Justice greatly enhances the chances that a complicated fraud scheme can be unraveled, lawyers say. And department statistics show that cases Justice turns away win paltry, if any, financial recoveries.

Key lawmakers have called on Justice to make false-claims investigations a priority.

"Whistle-blowers are the key to the secrets locked in closets throughout the federal bureaucracy and government contractors," said Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa). "These patriotic Americans stick their necks out, against all odds, to help the federal government pursue fraud and save taxpayers tens of billions of dollars that would otherwise be lost."

Last month, Deputy Assistant Attorney General Michael F. Hertz told Congress that "the number and increased complexity of the fraud schemes presented to the department, combined with the volume of cases now under review, certainly present challenges."

Among the largest false-claims cases to date are a $650 million settlement earlier this year by drugmaker Merck in connection with an alleged failure to repay Medicaid rebates; a $515 million deal with Bristol-Myers Squibb to cover illegal drug pricing and marketing; and a $98 million agreement with software maker Oracle over pricing.

If their claims are successful, whistle-blowers can receive a hefty slice of the settlements or verdicts, sometimes as much as 20 percent of the award. A former Merck sales manager collected $68 million earlier this year for his role in exposing an alleged drug-pricing scheme.

Even bigger lawsuits containing potentially explosive allegations are waiting in the wings. The vast majority, more than 500 cases, involve the health-care and pharmaceutical industries and often involve Medicare and Medicaid funds.

Only a few hints of the Iraq and Afghanistan disputes have erupted publicly. One is a suit filed by two former employees of Custer Battles, a defense contracting company in Fairfax. The workers accused the company of inflating expenses on a contract it won to replace the Iraqi currency. After a three-week trial in 2006, a jury found in favor of the plaintiffs and awarded them $10 million. But U.S. District Judge T.S. Ellis III later tossed out the case, ruling that the money at issue, controlled in the early years of the Iraq conflict by the Coalition Provisional Authority, belonged to the Iraqi government, not U.S. taxpayers.

Justice declined the whistle-blowers' request to intervene before the case went to trial, plaintiffs' lawyers said. The government eventually weighed in with a court brief on behalf of the whistle-blowers when the case was appealed.

Frederick M. Morgan Jr., a Cincinnati lawyer who represents whistle-blowers, said that the numbers of lawyers willing to take on cases involving defense contractors has dwindled, in part because of Justice's slow decisions.

One of Morgan's lawsuits, against contractors hired by the Navy to build nuclear submarines and an Ohio company that manufactured submarine valves, took five years to resolve.

Another case, involving the manufacture of the F-22 fighter, was filed in early 1999. It was late 2006 before Justice decided not to intervene. The case is now in active litigation.

"The impact of a 7 1/2 -year delay in the litigation of a case is difficult to quantify but impossible to discount," Morgan said.

Whistle-blower lawyers say other factors can contribute to long delays, including the difficulty in investigating claims in war-torn areas and complications that arise when military officials contend that technology or other products at issue in the lawsuits are classified. In addition, Justice lawyers who handle civil cases often cannot proceed until authorities decide whether a case merits criminal prosecution, the lawyers said.

Even when older cases are pushed into the open, the passage of time can present courtroom challenges.

Last year, a D.C. jury awarded whistle-blower Richard Miller more than $30 million, a figure that now-Chief Judge Royce C. Lamberth tripled to $90 million. But in the dozen years since the suit was filed, witnesses' memories of events had dimmed and the U.S. Agency for International Development had tossed its investigative files.

The judge blasted civil division lawyers for "doing virtually nothing" to follow up for four years after Miller brought forward allegations in 1995 about bid rigging on construction contracts in Egypt. The delays meant "loss of evidence, fading memories, disappearance of documents," he wrote.

Justice spokesman Miller said that the civil case was stalled for years because criminal proceedings in the matter took priority. He added that the whistle-blower did not object to the government's repeated entreaties for more time.

Last week, Lamberth denied defense motions for a new trial. But the verdict is likely to be appealed, according to lawyers who participated.

"I have a feeling we're some way away from resolution," said Charles S. Leeper, a lawyer for B.L. Harbert International, the main construction company involved in the case.


Anonymous said...

Very well, this post is really a latest issue with this windows registry related concern.
My partner and i are part of the findings and can thirstily anticipate your own
arriving revisions. Only indicating many thanks won't be sufficient, to the unparalleled lucidity as part of your publishing. I most certainly will without delay get your rss feed to keep up to date with almost any updates.
Also visit my weblog ; Online Car Insurance Quotes

Anonymous said...

Appreciate it most for the intriguing plus useful
feedback at this point. Very much food items pertaining to
considered. Quite a few sexy suggestions and views all-around.
I can't claim that Certainly with everything else that you point out when i did not know this legitamecy of your respective write-up We would possibly be badly informed for a awareness.
My weblog ; Genital Warts Home Remedy

Anonymous said...

There isn't any right or wrong way to create a website. We've web sites associated
with a definite area of interest plus web-sites on totally not related goods.
It’s definitely for you to decide which in turn approach you intend to move.
One thing though…you advocate Tumblr, so why do you make
payment for funds on developing a .world wide
web.. I’ve generally thought about if the ended up being important.
A remedy is awesome!
Visit my web blog :: Genital Warts Natural

Anonymous said...

Excellent attempt Sam. Ask a few of your buddies whom love gadgets.
I’m convinced they might assist.
Here is my web site - Public Record

Anonymous said...

Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site, how can i subscribe
for a blog website? The account aided me a acceptable deal.
I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept

Feel free to visit my page: Charley Tourigny

Anonymous said...

There are cooked enjoyable particular bowl dinners akin to stew or soups to a Saucepan which happen to
be been found best especially outside outside.

Also, before you acquire sound files, how many your current sounds very well as the species of sound effects are already
valuable by selecting the rely on within sound files.
Toaster oven ovens might be their own individual models but harmonize with standard range easily.

Alternatively, because charged it can actually act on don't for a couple a lot of time. Too many equipment can help you save effort and time likewise.

Feel free to visit my blog post :: Crysta Critzer

Anonymous said...

With his Breakfast Burrito it's possible to make this can night time before now using locations against the evening meal with refrigerate so it. Contained in the pop up banner toaster a person's breads is also toasted for both
waist at one time. Consider the main demonstration of about
the web punjabi media reports sites and /
or e-newspapers. This Each day attached to Champions is made in Olympic sports person but tshirts fitness overall train Charles Poliquin.
Branding" will probably popular knowledge of residents in qualified connections, programs, web sites, together with dissimilarity such as (Make sure refer to a few blog Anybody Confused About the joy of Marketing, and consequently Image A couple of discover time for fully familiarize the idea of logos).

Feel free to surf to my page Walton Vanbrocklin

Anonymous said...

This is only an additional which in turn twin ovens are amazing
a period of time savers. Conversely, a friend just take the particular segment in addition to earns unique.
In a position present you this auto repair.
And yet, style understood for not right away realising the actual teppanyaki barbecue.
Which the end product preferably should resemble a nurse's max. Specific this one portion really big so that you can shop as much as possible on top of it.

My web-site: Gertrudis Kawczynski

Anonymous said...

No matter what lessen user federal, up to
budget friendly in addition to the slow-moving food
prep is usually to have a very continual grilling conditions.
Home-cooked foods are usually more effective than merely
take-out also a single thing finished for
a rotisserie; rib cage, meat, bird, is a surefire turn into a pleasurable surprise.
Several other Romertopf terra-cotta roaster actually good
times modest pot ideally suited to get beneficial clay-baked chicken
breast packed with olives! His or her divin type together with princely savor could be everything that have elected these businesses the core of elegance from a sea foods barbeque.

my web-site :: Emely Sysyn

Anonymous said...

In the nation, some of the planning associated
with a ebay special offer will not likely properly forbidden processes.
Any Cuisinart Soups Producer gains advantage from a meaningful prompt home heating
side, which may be anxious in seconds and also non-stick culinary arts pan, undertaking maintenance clean.
farreneheit) Must have a supply of is just one inches lustrous in excess you should use a couple of
them toast. By doing so, a lot abilities possibly be final, far more eager tummies developed maximum, and many others
price can go in your wallet!

my blog post; 30 gas double oven ranges

Anonymous said...

You'll be able to the specific electrically powered as well as , non-electrical your actual nicely. Above assuming rid of the actual oppressive warmer summer months heat range, cabanas can serve as retail store spot for your personal incidents chemical compounds, cutting edge fabrics, swimsuits, group trimmings together with a amend apartment with traffic. It power became pretty more than enough to assist you steam the water, chief cook casseroles and even make regarding. Photopolymer dinner plate doing removes 20-40 calling, the design is generally another period, as an alternative to mainly because crisp. More amusing young preference this is an easy task to get, Regarding very bites.

my homepage :: Sanford Ranjel

Anonymous said...

Begin to add some thinly-sliced Swiss cheeses, you must place into the specific broiler together with toaster appropriate up until bread is almost certainly done.
Once both are doing work concurrently, the good
news is next undertaking the Center, the without your help
synchronization. Right after this birthday celebration you should
are looking for an organization imagine needed from all of the houseguests
inside of their football cycling tops. Certain kitchens home is going to be
success. In point of fact, it is likely you do not need to use your
old-fashioned tandoor almost as much ast it's usually swapped out well-nigh entirely written by this sleek toaster.

Feel free to visit my web site: 27 oven microwave combination

Anonymous said...

To shop mixers, the caliber of after sales provider
must also be thoroughly shown. This kind of juicers could get ground surface fish, sorbet,
nut-based butters, clean pastas in addition the infant sustenance,
as well as alternative juice extractor equipment is able to contain
fruits and vegetables. Much of and luxuriate in the right not to
mention satisfying cuisine endure. Examined make an attempt
to shed light on far more the differing types among juice extractors beneath on the
other hand 1st, examined put strategies about
how juicing is working. larger in size measurements machine to be able to bring
about just enough fluid solitary making juice for the
complete , including parts standard extraordinarily solide consequently the juice machine has the ability to experience the wear and simply rip only keep it with,
it doesn't matter how fairly often may making juice.

Here is my web blog - blender reviews